Interested in learning more about the topics covered in this post? See more of Robyn’s insights on:

The 3 hidden financial traps of cottage ownership

by | Jun 25, 2014 | SELF-PUBLISHED

It’s not all piney woods and gorgeous sunsets

The cabin in the woods or cottage by the lake can make a great retreat from the big smoke. But with vacation properties in prime areas pushing a million bucks or more, buying one has become a major financial planning challenge. And if you already have a cottage in the family, there may be looming ownership, tax, and estate-planning problems if you’re thinking of selling or transferring to a new generation. Here are the three top issues to be aware of whether you already own a vacation property or you’re contemplating buying one.

1. Your tax partner

All cottage owners have a silent partner – the Canada Revenue Agency. That’s because of something called the “principal residence exemption.” A principal residence is a dwelling that someone ordinarily inhabits at some point during the year. That can include a vacation property. Effectively, it means you don’t pay capital gains tax when you sell the property you designate as your principal residence. Our tax laws state that a couple can have only one principal residence. For most of us, that’s our home in town.

When you sell your recreational property, then, you’ll pay capital gains tax on an appreciation in the value of the property from when you purchased it. So along with all those ongoing maintenance costs, property taxes, and other expenses associated with ownership of a vacation property, you’ll be paying a good chunk of any gain in value (less improvements, so keep those receipts) to the federal government – something north of 20% at least.

2. The principal residence conundrum

In fact, there’s nothing to stop you from designating your vacation property as a principal residence and claiming the exemption on it. But you’d do this only if it makes financial sense – for example, if the average annual gain on the vacation property exceeds the gain on your home.

Remember, too, that unless you report the gain on the sale of your vacation property, the CRA will assume you have designated it as your principal residence. So be sure to discuss which property to designate as your principal residence with your financial planner before you put that cottage up for sale.

3. All in the family

Many people have sentimental reasons for keeping a vacation property in the family by transferring it to children or grandchildren. Depending on your family situation, this may or may not be a good idea. Some family members may want to keep the property, others may want to sell it for the cash. Either way, taxes will have to be paid in the event of a transfer.

Sometimes, the tax bill can be reduced if parents or grandparents took advantage of something called “Valuation Day,” January 1, 1972, which involved assigning an acceptable value to the property as of that date. Essentially, any capital gain before that date will not be subject to capital gains tax. The V-day value (less improvements made since then) for these types of properties is considered to be the adjusted cost base for determining capital gains tax. But that could still be significant, even if you can whittle down the adjusted cost base by deducting capital improvements made over the intervening 40 years.

Transferring the title to the recreational property to your kids or grandkids, or holding title in joint tenancy cannot be used to circumvent the tax bill. The CRA will still treat any such transfer as a deemed sale, and demand you pay capital gains tax.

Some owners try to keep a cottage in the family without incurring a deemed sale by holding the property “in trust.” But you actually have to create a trust for this purpose and go through all the legal procedures to make this happen. The CRA is highly skeptical of claims for recreational properties held “in trust” where no legal trust exists. So if you want to create a trust, you’re going to need expert legal help.

Rather than going through all these machinations, many cottage owners simply opt to purchase life insurance that will cover the tax on the deemed sale of the property on the death of the owner. Here again, you’re going to need some knowledgeable financial help, because it’s easy to buy too much insurance.

If you’re thinking about buying that slice of paradise by the lake, or are thinking about selling or transferring ownership, your best bet is to consult a Certified Financial Planner with insurance expertise who can help you navigate the many legal and tax pitfalls that accompany cottage ownership.

© 2014 by Robyn K. Thompson. All rights reserved. Reproduction without permission is prohibited.

© 2023 by Robyn K. Thompson. All rights reserved. Reproduction without permission is prohibited. This article is for information only and is not intended as personal investment or financial advice.

Related posts:


Are your bank deposits protected?

U.S., European bank failures raise anxiety level Are your bank deposits safe? Will deposit insurance protect you if a Canadian bank runs into trouble? It’s a question many people are asking,...

Pin It on Pinterest