Is your portfolio a risk trap?

How to get a fix on portfolio holdings before it’s too late!

Do-it-yourself investors who have a number of different investment accounts could be courting financial trouble. Unless you have a complete picture of how all your assets are allocated, your investment picture could be a lot riskier than you thought. Here’s how to find out.

Unless your assets are already with a qualified portfolio manager, you are unlikely to get detailed regular reports on your asset allocations. Your brokerage or account statements will show holdings, transactions, and values, but not much more. That’s because these separate accounts are not set up as a complete portfolio. This can be problematic if you have several different accounts at different financial firms. If you’re in this situation, you’ll have to do some basic account spreadsheet work on your own.

  1. Open your statements…and read them!

Check your account statements for all holdings, the current total value the portfolio, and the individual value of all holdings. Make sure you include assets in both registered (e.g., RRSP, TFSA, etc.) and non-registered (e.g., brokerage or direct accounts) and both self-directed and discretionary accounts. This will let you calculate the relative percentage weighting of each item in your total portfolio.

  1. Sort your assets

This step is relatively easy. Financial assets fall mainly into three broad categories: cash (including liquid instruments such as Treasury bills and money market funds); fixed-income (usually bonds, but preferred shares are also sometimes included); equities (stocks, stock options, trust units). A fourth category, call it “alternative investments,” might include futures contracts and options, commodities, and currencies, but this won’t apply to most investors.

Sort your holdings into these categories, and include mutual funds and exchange-traded funds according to how they are weighted – e.g., a 50/50 balanced mutual fund would be allocated equally between fixed-income and equity. This lets you see how much you have in each category. For example, it might turn out that you might have 80% of your assets in equities and only 20% in cash and fixed income. Or your portfolio might be predominantly weighted to bonds or bond funds.

  1. What on earth are you investing in?

Next, drill down to determine what sector each asset belongs in. The broad equity sectors are basic materials, conglomerates, consumer goods, financial, healthcare, industrial, services, technology, and utilities. If in doubt, look up your stock holding online to see what sector it belongs in. Ditto for geographic exposure to determine whether your portfolio is diversified globally, or whether there’s too much concentration in a region that’s underperforming. For bonds, classify holdings as government or corporate (and in corporate, sub-classify by risk ranking).

Investment fund holdings are slightly more complicated, because they are typically already diversified internally. However, you can get a preliminary fix on the broad sector of your mutual fund or ETF by checking which fund category it is placed in. In Canada, one widely-used fund category system is administered by the Canadian Investment Fund Standards Committee (CIFSC). Each fund breaks down its holdings by category, sector, and region on dedicated fund information pages and fact sheets located on the fund company’s website.

  1. Is your portfolio a risk trap?

You’re now getting a pretty good picture of your asset allocation, and sector weightings. You’ll quickly see whether your portfolio is overweighted in equities or fixed income, and whether it’s dominated by one or two stocks, and if so, what kind of stocks they are. If you find your portfolio is tilted in a direction you don’t like (for example, an overweight in risky equities), you can then take appropriate action to “rebalance.” Rebalancing is an art in and of itself, because it involves selling selected assets in one category and purchasing assets in another. Of course, this can have tax implications, as well as transaction costs.

Your best course of action might be to consult a qualified fee-for-service financial advisor who will undertake your portfolio review, sort your holdings into a spreadsheet, and suggest a cost-effective course of action if one is necessary to bring your portfolio in line with your tolerance for risk and your longer-term financial objectives.

© 2015 by Robyn K. Thompson. All rights reserved. Reproduction without permission is prohibited. This article is for information only and is not intended as personal investment or financial advice.

Is your portfolio a risk trap? was last modified: December 6th, 2015 by robyn